Numerical Investigation of Geometrical Effects on the Flow Hydrodynamics in Tangential Vortex Drop Shaft

Document Type : Original Research

Authors
F. Golriz 1
S. Salehi neyshaburi 2
1 Ph.D. student of Water and Hydraulic Structures Engineering, Faculty of Civil&Environmental Eng., Tarbiat Modares University
2 Professor of Hydraulic Structures Engineering, Water Engineering Research Institute, Tarbiat Modares University
10.22034/23.6.10
Abstract
Vortex drops are compact hydraulic structures used in surface water and sewer collection systems to convey runoff from higher to lower elevations by creating a rotational flow inside vertical shafts. These structures are composed of three main parts: the intake, drop shaft, and dissipation chamber. Tangential intake is a steep tapering channel that generally has a junction with a rectangular approach channel with the horizontal bottom at the beginning and a narrow slot at the connection with the drop shaft. Many factors need to consider in the design of vortex drop shafts with proper hydraulic performance. The review of previous studies and the guideline designs for this structure indicates that most design relations were obtained either based on simplified assumptions or by conducting limited tests on laboratory scale models, which can cause desirable operation in practice. These conditions have forced engineers to set up laboratory models or numerical simulations of the initial design to evaluate the proper performance of the structure in big projects. With this introduction, one of the problems in the surface water collection network of Tehran is conveying high volumes of runoff from the surface of streets at the highway intersections to a lower level in the underground tunnels or pipes. Therefore the authorities pay more attention to necessary considerations in the design and use of these types of structures for the safe transfer of runoff downstream. In this paper, using numerical modeling, the hydrodynamics of flow in a real vortex drop shaft with tangential intake has been studied. In the design stage, a vortex drop structure in Tehran's urban drainage has been selected and evaluated by the Flow-3D numerical model. Based on the latest available design methods, Several tangential intakes with different geometry were assessed separately. Finally, the performance of the final drop shaft was simulated and analyzed using the numerical model. The final design simulation results showed that the flow in the tangential intake would enter the vertical shaft without forming a hydraulic jump. The flow in the vertical shaft is spirally attached to the wall with a central air core. A key design parameter is the ratio of the air core area to the drop shaft cross-sectional area that was greater than 0.49. The efficiency of energy losses at the tangential intake is about (9-15%), in the vertical shaft is about (23-40%), and in the energy dissipating chamber is (70-71%) depending on the flow rate. The energy loss efficiency in the whole structure was about (80-84%). The depth size needed to create a water cushion in the energy dissipation chamber was considered for three depths of 0.4D, 0.5D, and 0.6D. After numerical modeling, the appropriate depth for the water cushion was determined to be 0.6D. The results of the simulations indicated that the use of existing design methods only sometimes leads to optimal hydraulic performance in the structure. Therefore, reviewing the existing design methods, simulating the flow in the designed drop shaft, or setting up a laboratory model before finalizing the design is necessary.

Keywords

Subjects

[1] Bhosekar, V.V., Deolalikar, P. B. and Sridevi, M. I., (2007). “Hydraulic design aspects for swirling flow at vertical drop shaft.” ISH Journal of Hydraulic Engineering. Vol. 13, NO.3, Pages 78-89.
[2] Drioli, C. (1969). “Esperienze su installazioni con pozzo di scarico a vortice.” L’Energia Elettrica, 46(6), 399–409.
[3] Jain, S. C., and Kennedy, J. F., (1983). “Vortex-Flow Drop Structures for the Milwaukee Metropolitan Sewerage District Inline Storage System.” Iowa Institute of Hydraulic Research, The University of Iowa, Iowa City, Iowa, Report No. 264.
[4] Jain, S., (1984). “Tangential vortex-inlet.” Journal of Hydraulic Engineering, ASCE, 110(12), 1693-1699.
[5] Jain, S. (1987). “Free-surface swirling flows in vertical dropshaft.” Journal of Hydraulic Engineering, ASCE, 113(10), 1277–1289.
[6] Hager, W. (1985). “Head-discharge relation for vortex shaft.” Journal of Hydraulic Engineering, ASCE, 111(6), 1015–1020.
[7] Hager, W. (1990). “Vortex drop inlet for supercritical approaching flow.” Journal of Hydraulic Engineering, ASCE, 116(8), 1048–1054.
[8] Vischer, D. L., and Hager, W. H. (1995). “Vortex drops.” Energy dissipators: Hydraulic structures design manual, No. 9, Chap. 9, A. A. Balkema, Rotterdam, The Netherlands, 167–181.
[9] Renyong Jia, Shanfa Zhang, and Long Hu, (2012). “Numerical simulation of hydraulic characteristics in a tangential vortex dropshaft”. Advanced Materials Research, Vols. 594-597, pp 2066-2069.
[10] Zhao, C., Zhu, D., Sun, S., and Liu, Z. (2006). “Experimental study of flow in a vortex drop shaft.” Journal of Hydraulic Engineering, ASCE, 132(1), 61-68.
[11] Nielsen, K. D. and Davis, A. L. (2008). “CFD analysis of vortex dropshaft structure.” World Environmental and Water Resources Congress, Ahupua'a.
[12] Wai, O.W.H., Li, C.W., Xu, Q.H., Zhan, J. M., Chan, P.K. and Yu, J., (2009). “Hybrid modeling of the hydraulic performance of a stormwater vortex drop intake with a curved approach channel.” 33rd IAHR Congress: Water Engineering for a Sustainable Environment
[13] Yu, D.Y. and Lee, J.H.W., (2009). “Hydraulics of tangential vortex intake for urban drainage.” Journal of Hydraulic Engineering, ASCE, 135(3), 164-174.
[14] Auckland, A., Nistor, I. and Townsend, R. (2009). “Intake shape and boundary-related considerations in the operation and design of storm-sewer drop structures.” Can. J. Civ. Eng. 36: 1825–1834.
[15] Giudice, G., Gisonni, C., and Rasulo, G. (2010). “Design of a scroll vortex inlet for supercritical approach flow.” Journal of Hydraulic Engineering, ASCE, 136(10), 837-841.
[16] Del Giudice, G., Gisonni, C. and Rasulo, G. (2008a). “Vortex shaft outlet.” Proceedings of the 16th IAHR-APD Congress and 3rd International Symposium on Hydraulic Structures. Nanjing, China. Vol. 6, 2053-2058.
[17] Chen Hua-yong, Xu Wei-lin, Deng Jun, Niu Zhi-pan, Liu Shan-jun and Wang Wei, (2010). “Theoretical and experimental studies of hydraulic characteristics of discharge tunnel with vortex drop.” Journal of Hydrodynamics, 22(4), 582-589
[18] Chen, H., Deng, J., Hu, J., Xie, B., Liu, B. and Liu, J. (2008). “Experimental study on inner velocity and energy dissipation of shaft spillway with whirling.” Proceedings of 16th IAHR-APD Congress and 3rd Symposium of IAHR-ISHS.
[19] Mulligan, S., Casserly, J., Sherlock, R., (2014). “Hydrodynamic Investigation of Free-Surface Turbulent Vortex Flows with Strong Circulation in a Vortex Chamber”, 5th IAHR International Junior Researcher and Engineer Workshop on Hydraulic Structures, Spa, Belgium.
[20] Pfister, M., Crispino, G., Fuchsmann, T., Ribi, J.M. and Gisonni, C., (2018). “Multiple Inflow Branches at Supercritical-Type Vortex Drop Shaft.” Journal of Hydraulic Engineering, ASCE, 144(11), 1–9.
[21] Zhang, W., Wang, J., Zhou, Ch., Dong, Z. and Zhou, Zh., (2018). “Numerical Simulation of Hydraulic Characteristics in A Vortex Drop Shaft.” Water 10, No. 10: 1393.
[22] Liu, Zh., Guo, X., Xia, Q. and Fu, H., (2018). “Experimental and Numerical Investigation of Flow in a Newly Developed Vortex Drop Shaft Spillway.” Journal of Hydraulic Engineering, ASCE, 144(5), 1–11.
[23] Carty, A., O’ Neill, Co., Nash, S., Clifford, Eo. & Mulligan, S., (2019) "Hydrodynamic modelling approaches to assess mechanisms affecting the structural performance and maintenance of vortex drops shaft structures." Journal of Structural Integrity and Maintenance, 4:3, 162-178
[24] Yang Z, Yin J, Lu Y, Liu Z, Yang H, Xu G., (2021). "Three-Dimensional Flow of a Vortex Drop Shaft Spillway with an Elliptical Tangential Inlet" Water 13, no. 4: 504.
[25] Hajiahmadi, A., Ghaeini-Hessaroeyeh, M. and Khanjani, M.J., (2021). “Experimental Study of Flow Characteristics in Vortex Drop Shaft.” Journal of Pipeline Systems Engineering and Practice, ASCE, 12(1), 1–9.
[26] Chang, Lu, and Wangru Wei., (2022). "Numerical study on the effect of tangential intake on vortex drop shaft assessment using pressure distributions." Engineering Applications of Computational Fluid Mechanics, 161, 1100-1110.
[27] Flow Science Co., Flow-3D Version 11.2., Users Manual.
[28] Report of hydraulic investigation of the vortex structure in the surface water collection systems of Tehran, M1 system (Shahid Kharazi highway), Rahab Consulting Engineers, 2016, (In Persian).
[29] Report of hydraulic investigation of the vortex drop shaft on the east side of sewage of Tehran (Sayad Shirazi highway), Design & Construction Caspian consulting engineers, Report, 2011, (In Persian).
[30] Jain, S. and Ettema, R. (1987). “Vortex flow intakes.” Swirling flow problems at intakes, IAHR Hydraulic Structures Design Manual, J. Knauss, ed., Vol. 1, A.A.Balkema, Rotterdam, Netherlands, 125–137.
Modares Civil Engineering journal
Volume 23, Issue 6
November and December 2023
Pages 143-157