Evaluation of effective parameters on Break-off test results for determining strength of steel fiber reinforced concrete

Authors
B. ganjeh khosravi
H. ghasem zadeh
J. razzaghi
Abstract
Here, the efficiency of the non-destructive Break-Off (BO) test was investigated for assessing the in-place compressive strength of steel fiber reinforced concrete (SFRC). SFRC was studied due to its advantages in increasing toughness and tensile and flexural strength in particular. To provide a through and comprehensive database, 24 mix designs were selected with cement contents of 400, 450 and 500 kg/m3 with constant water/cement ratio of 0.4 for all mixes, two maximum aggregate sizes of 12.5 and 25 mm along with steel fiber volume fractions of 0%, 0.33%, 0.67% and 1% for ages of 14, 28 and 90 days. A total of 360 BO tests and 216 standard cube tests were carried out in this investigation.Then, effective parameters of SFRC and BO test results were evaluated. In the BO method, the force required to break off an in-place concrete cylinder of 55 mm in diameter and 70 mm long, is related to the compressive strength of the concrete from a predetermined calibration curve developed for concrete mix.The studies showed that volumetric percentage and features of steel fibers had a significant influence on concrete properties as well as BO test results. According to the experimental results it could be generally concluded that the influencing factors, namely, SFRC properties due to presence of steel fibers and BO test significantly affect the results as follows: Generally, for a constant W/C ratio, it can be concluded that raising the cement content increase the mean values of BO strength. It can be stated that the maximum aggregate size within the range of 12.5–25 mm has a negligible effect on the BO test results for SFRC with 1% steel fiber volume fractions as the average value of BO strength for 25 mm aggregate concrete was significantly more than the corresponding value for 12.5 mm aggregate size for plain concrete. Moreover, the improving trend the BO strength with age is observed to be similar for all different concretes. Furthermore, increase of BO strength of SFR concretes respect to corresponding plain value is observed as concrete grows older. In addition, results showed that strength estimation based on a single general calibration curve is not feasible. Therefore, a specific calibration curve for each SFRC should be represented for a realistic assessment and interpretation of results. The coefficient of variation of the BO strength was in range of 4– 11%. The higher values are for concretes with higher amounts of fibers, especially at early ages. The reliability of the method seems to be good in which the coefficient of variation for each group of BO tests are below 11%. It should be noted that even under ideal conditions with a specific calibration it is unlikely that 95% confidence limits of better than ±15% can be achieved for an absolute prediction of concrete compressive strength. The findings show that higher values are not only due to the lack of precision of the test procedure, but also due to the intrinsic heterogeneity of granular materials like concrete, particularly in presence of higher amounts of fibers.

Keywords

Subjects

[1] Bungey J. H., Millard S. G., Grantham M.G., Testing of concrete in structures, 4th ed., Taylor & Francis, London and New York, 2006, 352p.
[2] Long AE, Murray AMcC. The pull-off partially destructive test for concrete. In: Malhotra VM, editor. Proc. Int. Conf. on In-SiturNon-Destructive Testing of Concrete, Ottawa, Canada, October. ACI SP-82, 1984:327-350.
[3] Neville A. M., Properties of concrete, 4th ed., John Wiley and Sons, Inc., New York, 1996, 844p.
[4] Johansen R., a new method for determination of in-place concrete strength of form removal, 1st Eur. Colloq. on Construction Quality Control, Madrid, Spain, 1976.
[5] Johansen R. In Situ strength Evaluation of Concrete The Break-off Method. Concrete International. 1979 Sep 1;1(09):45-51.
[6] Byfors, Jan. Plain concrete at early ages. No. 80. Swedish Cement and Concrete Research Institute, 1980.
[7] Dahl-Jorgensen E, Johansen R. General and specialized use of the break-off concrete strength testing method. Special Publication. 1984 Sep 1;82:293-308.
[8] Dahl-Jorgensen E. Break-Off and Pull-Off Methods for Testing Epoxy-Concrete Bonding Strength. Project No. 160382, The Foundation of Scientific and Industrial Research of the Norwegian Institute of Technology, Trondheim, Norway, 1982.
[9] Carlsson M, Eeg IR, Jahren P. Field experience in the use of the “break-off tester”. Special Publication. 1984 Sep 1;82:277-92.
[10] Lin Y, Lin YF, Hsiao C. Evaluation of bond quality at the interface between steel bar and concrete using the small-dimension break-off test. Materials and Structures. 2010 Jun 1;43(5):583-95.
[11]Li VC. Large volume, high-performance applications of fibers in civil engineering. Journal of Applied Polymer Science. 2002 Jan 18;83(3):660-86.
[12] Aydin A,. Self compactability of high volume hybrid fiber reinforced concrete. Construction and Building Materials. 2007 Jun 30;21(6):1149-54.
[13] Xu Z, Hao H, Li HN,. Mesoscale modelling of fibre reinforced concrete material under compressive impact loading. Construction and Building Materials. 2012 Jan 31;26(1):274-88.
[14] Khalaj G, Nazari A,. Modeling split tensile strength of high strength self compacting concrete incorporating randomly oriented steel fibers and SiO2 nanoparticles. Composites Part B: Engineering. 2012 Jun 30;43(4):1887-92.
[15] Luccioni B, Ruano G, Isla F, Zerbino R, Giaccio G. A simple approach to model SFRC. Construction and Building Materials. 2012 Dec 31;37:111-24.
[16] Xu Z, Hao H, Li HN. Mesoscale modelling of dynamic tensile behaviour of fibre reinforced concrete with spiral fibres. Cement and Concrete Research. 2012 Nov 30;42(11):1475-93.
[17] British Standard, B.S. 1881, Part 201, 1986, 17.
[18] ASTM C 1150 (1992) Standard test method for the break-off number of concrete, vol 04.02. Annual Book of ASTM Standards
[19] EN, BS. 12390-3. Testing hardened concrete. Compressive strength of test specimens 19 (2009).
[20] Nikbin, I. M., M. H. A. Beygi, M. T. Kazemi, J. Vaseghi Amiri, E. Rahmani, S. Rabbanifar, and M. Eslami. A comprehensive investigation into the effect of aging and coarse aggregate size and volume on mechanical properties of self-compacting concrete. Materials & Design 59 (2014): 199-210.
[21] Vu, Xuan Hong, Laurent Daudeville, and Yann Malecot. Effect of coarse aggregate size and cement paste volume on concrete behavior under high triaxial compression loading. Construction and Building Materials 25.10 (2011): 3941-3949.
[22] El-Dieb, A. S., Reda Taha, MM,. Flow characteristics and acceptance criteria of fiber- reinforced self-compacted concrete (FR-SCC). Construction and Building Materials 27.1 (2012); 585-596.
[23] Khayat, K., Schutter, D,. Mechanical Properties of Self-Compacting Concrete. State-or-the-art report of RILEM Technical Committee 228-MPS (2013); Vol. 14, springer.
[24] Madandoust, R,. Ranjbar, M,. Ghavidel, R,. Shahabi, F,. Assessment of factors influencing mechanical properties of steel fiber reinforced self-compacting concrete. Materials & Design 83 (2015): 284-294.

[25] Aslani, F, Nejadi S,. Self-compacting concrete incorporating steel and polypropylene fibers: Compressive and tensile strengths, moduli of elasticity and rupture, compressive stress–strain curve, and energy dissipated under compression. Composites Part B: Engineering 53 (2013): 121-133.
[26] Güneyisi, E,. Combined effect of steel fiber and metakaolin incorporation on mechanical properties of concrete. Composites Part B: Engineering 56 (2014): 83-91.
[27] AL-Ameeri A,. The effect of steel fiber on some mechanical properties of self compacting concrete. American Journal of civil engineering (2013): 102-110.
[28] Alyousif, A,. Design and Testing of Fiber Reinforced Self Compacting Concrete. PhD diss., Eastern Mediterranean University (EMU), 2010.
[29] Martinie, L., Roussel, N,.Simple tools for fiber orientation prediction in industrial practice. Cement and Concrete research 41.10 (2011): 993-1000.
[30] Zerbino, R., et al. On the orientation of fibres in structural members fabricated with self compacting fibre reinforced concrete. Cement and Concrete Composites 34.2 (2012): 191-200.
[31] Ghavidel, R., Madandoust, R., Ranjbar, M.,. reliability of pull-of test for steel fiber reinforced self-compacting concrete." Measurement 73 (2015): 628-639
Modares Civil Engineering journal
Volume 18, Issue 2
July and August 2018
Pages 203-212