Improving the Performance of the Square Shallow Foundations using Inferior Skirts

Authors
M. Makarchian 1
S. gholipour 2
1 Assistant Professor,‍Civil Engineering Department, Faculty of Engineering, Bu-Ali Sina University, Hamedan
2 phd candidate bu ali sina university
Abstract
Development of the new type of improvement methods of shallow foundations in the geotechnical engineering, it seems necessary to study the performance of vertical plates beneath the periphery of shallow foundations known as skirted foundations. Skirted foundations are steel or concrete foundations, which have a top raft and a relatively thin plate constructed beneath the periphery. The skirts penetrate the soil beneath foundation which encompass and confine the soil very firmly. The skirts and confined soil behave as a unit to transmit loads to the soil at the level of skirt tip. The benefit of skirted foundations compared with deep foundations such as piers and piles lies in their ease and short time of installations. The skirted foundations can be used as an appropriate alternative for shallow foundations, pier and deep foundations in applications such as oil and gas storage tanks, wind turbines, oil drilling platforms, harbor, and offshore and jacket structures. The behavior of square shallow foundations resting on confined sand by vertical plates as skirt, was studied using small scale physical modeling in the laboratory. The effects of parameters including ratio of skirt length to foundation width, foundation size, the shear strength of sand, and roughness of skirt and foundation surfaces on skirted foundations behavior in terms of increasing bearing capacity, the settlement reduction, and improvement of subgrade reaction modulus were assessed under compression loading, and results compared with the performance of shallow and pier foundations. Modeling test analyses revealed the overall improvement of square skirted foundations performance compared to shallow and pier foundations. Results of this study showed that the values of bearing capacity and settlement of skirted foundations are almost close to those of pier foundations of the same width and depth. Also, it was observed that the existence of skirt, increases the bearing capacity and modulus of subgrade reaction, together with decrease of settlement of shallow foundation. The enhancement in the bearing capacity, as well as reduction in the settlement of shallow foundations increases with increasing skirt depth and decreasing the shear strength of sand. So that, bearing capacity ratio (BCR) of skirted foundations to surface foundations was observed in the range of about 2.4 to 5.1 times for the different values of L/B. Furthermore, the value of skirted foundation settlement decreased up to 91% of that a surface foundation in the case of having skirt depth/ foundation width of 2.0. The modulus of subgrade reaction improved in the range of about 1.5 to 4.23 times duo to skirt existence. From the accomplished laboratory tests, it was found that skirted foundations resting on loose sand, are more beneficial than in case of resting on medium and dense sand. In cases where structures are very sensitive to settlement values, the skirted foundations can be used to gain the same allowable bearing capacity a much lower settlement. In this paper, based on the analysis of the obtained results, charts and equations are presented to estimate bearing capacity and settlement and subgrade reaction modulus of skirted shallow foundations in terms of those of surface foundation and sand relative density, skirt depth to foundation width ratio and its roughness.

Keywords

[1]                Tjelta T. I. & Haaland G. 1993 Novel foundation concept for a jacket finding its place. Offshore site investigation and foundation behavior, Society for Underwater Technology, 28, 717–728.
[2]                Rusaas P., Aas-Jakobsen A., Barrett G., Christiansen P. E. & Baerheim M. 1995 Design, operations planning and experience from the marine operations for the Europipe jacket with bucket foundations. Proc. Offshore Technol. Conf., OTC 7794, Houston, TX, 885–895.
[3]                Erbrich C. T. & Tjelta T. I. 1999 Installation of bucket foundations and suction caissons in sand: geotechnical performance. Offshore Technology Conference, Houston, TX.
[4]                Lacasse S. 1999 Ninth OTRC Honors Lecture: Geotechnical Contributions to Offshore Development. Offshore Technology Conference, Paper 10822.
[5]                Jostad H. P. & Andersen K. H. 2006 Potential benefits of Using Skirted Foundations for Jackup Platforms. Offshore Technology Conference.
[6]                Houlsby G. T., Ibsen L. B. & Byrne B. B. 2005 Suction caissions for wind turbines. In: Gourvenec, Cassidy (Eds.), Frontiers in Offshore Geotechnics, Taylors and Francis group, London.
[7]                Tani K. & Craig W. H. 1995 Bearing capacity of circular foundations on soft clay of strength increasing with depth. Soils & Foundations, 35(4).
[8]                Hung L. C. & Kim S. R. 2012 Evaluation of vertical and horizontal bearing capacities of bucket foundations in clay. Ocean Engineering, 52, 75–82.
[9]                Bransby M. F. & Randolph M. F. 1999 The effect of embedment depth on the undrained response of skirted foundations to combined loading. Soils and Foundations, 39(4), 19–33.
[10]             Andersen K. H. & Jostad H. P. 1999 Foundation design of skirted foundations and anchors in clay. Offshore Technology Conference, Houston, Texas, 3-6.
[11]             Al-Aghbari M. Y. & Mohamedzein Y. E. A. 2004 Bearing capacity of strip foundations with structural skirts. Journal of Geotechnical and Geological Engineering, 22(1), 43–57.
[12]             Al-Aghbari M. Y. & Mohamedzein Y. E. A. 2006 Improving the performance of circular foundations using structural skirts. Ground Improvement, 10(3), 125-132.
[13]             Eid H. T., Alansari O. A., Odeh A. M., Nasr M. N. & Sadek H. A. 2009 A comparative study on the behavior of square foundations resting on confined sand. Can. Geotech. J., 46(4), 438–453.
[14]             Eid H. T. 2013 Bearing capacity and settlement of skirted shallow foundations on sand. International Journal of Geomechanics, 13(5), 645–652.
[15]             El-Sawwaf M. E. I. & Nazer A. 2005 Behavior of circular footings on confined granular soil. Journal of Geotechnical and Geoenvironmental Engineering, ASCE, 131(3), 359–366.
[16]             Nazir A. K. & Azzam W. R. 2010 Improving the bearing capacity of footing on soft clay with sand pile with/without skirts. Alexandria Engineering Journal, 49, 371–377.
[17]             Zhang P., Guo Y., Liu Y. & Ding H. 2016 Experimental study on installation of hybrid bucket foundations for offshore wind turbines in silty clay. Ocean Engineering, 114, 87-100.
[18]             Lu P. & Maclaren D. 2016 Geotechnical challenge of offshore mud-mat foundation stability: Combining analytical and finite element investigation of bearing capacity of sand overlying soft clay. Geomechanics for Energy and the Environment.
[19]             Mana D. S. K., Gourvenec S. & Randolph M. F. 2011 A numerical study of the vertical bearing capacity of skirted foundations. Frontiers in Offshore Geotechnics II- Taylor & Francis Group, London.
[20]             Azzam W. R. 2015 Finite element analysis of skirted foundation adjacent to sand slope under earthquake loading. HBRC Journal, 11, 231–239.
[21]             Wang X., Zeng X., Yu H. & Wang H. 2015 Centrifuge modeling of offshore wind turbine with bucket foundation under earthquake loading. Int. Foundation Congress and Equipment Expo, San Antonio, Texax.
[22]             Rad N. S. & Tumay M. T. 1987 Factors affecting sand specimen preparation by raining. Geotechnical Testing Journal, 10(1), 31-37.
[23]             Cerato A. B. & Lutenegger A. J. 2006 Bearing capacity of square and circular footings on a finite layer of granular soil underlain by a rigid base. Journal of Geotechnical and Geoenvironmental Engineering, 132(11), 1496–1501.
[24]             Pfeifle T. W. & Das B. M. 1979 Model tests for bearing capacity in sand. Journal of Geotechnical Engineering, 105, 1112-1116.
[25]             Chen Q. 2007 An Experimental Study on Characteristics and Behavior of Reinforced Soil Foundation. PhD Thesis, Louisiana State University, USA.
[26]             ASTM 2006, Standard Practice for Classification of Soils for Engineering Purposes (Unified Soil Classification System), ASTM standard D2487, West Conshohocken, PA.
[27]             LoPresti D. C. F., Pedroni S. & Crippa V. 1992 Maximum dry density of cohesionless soils by pluviation and by ASTM D 4253-83: A comparative study. Geotechnical Testing Journal, 15(2), 180-189.
[28]             Vaid Y. P. & Negussey D. 1984 Relative density of pluviated sand samples. Soils and Foundations, 24(2), 101-105.
[29]             Kusakabe O., Maeda Y. & Ohuchi M. 1992 Large-scale loading tests of shallow footing in pneumatic caisson. Journal of Geotechnical Engineering, 118(11), 1681-1695. 
[30]             Herle I. & Tejchman J. 1997 Effect of grain size and pressure level on bearing capacity of footings on sand. IS-Nagoya’97: Deformation and Progressive Failure in Geomechanics, T. Adachi, and F. Oka, Pergamon, Oxford, 781–786.
[31]             Tatsuoka F., Okahara M., Tanaka T., Tani K., Morimoto T. & Siddiquee M. S. A. 1991 Progressive failure and particle size effect in bearing capacity of a footing on sand. Geotech. Spec. Pub., 27(2), 788–802.
[32]             Ueno K., Miura K., Kusakabe O. & Nishimura M. 2001 Reappraisal of size effect of bearing capacity from plastic solution. Journal of Geotechnical and Geoenvironmental Engineering, 127(3), 275-281.
[33]             Vesić A. S. 1973 Analysis of ultimate loads of shallow foundations. Journal of Soil Mechanics and Foundations Division, 991, 45–73.
[34]             Shirashi S. 1990 Variation in bearing capacity factors of dense sand assessed by model loading tests. Soils and Foundations, 30(1), 17-26.
[35]             Zhu F., Clark J. I. & Phillips R. 2001 Scale effect of strip and circular footings resting on dense sand. Journal of Geotechnical and Geoenvironmental Engineering, 1277, 613–621.
[36]             Cerato A. B. & Lutengger A. J. 2007 Scale effects of shallow foundation bearing capacity on granular material. J. of Geotech. Geoenviron. Eng., 133(10), 1192–1202.
[37]             DeBeer E. E. 1965 Bearing capacity and settlement of shallow foundations on sand. Proc. of the Symposium on Bearing Capacity and Settlement of Foundations, Durham, 15-33.
[38]             Loukidis D. & Salgado R. 2011 Effect of relative density and stress level on the bearing capacity of footings on sand. Geotechnique, 61(2), 107–119.
[39]             Meyerhof G. G. 1963 Some recent research on the bearing capacity of foundations. Canadian Geotechnical Journal, 1(1), 16–26.
[40]             Hansen J. B. 1970 A revised and extended formula for bearing capacity. Bulletin No. 28, Danish Geotech. Ins., Copenhagen, 5–11.
[41]             Lundgren H. & Moetensen K. 1953 Determination by theory of plasticity on the Bearing capacity of continuous footing on sand. Proc., 3th Int. Conf. Soil Mech. Found. Eng., 1, 409-412.
[42]             Spangler M. G. & Handy R. L. 1982 Soil Engineering. 4th Ed., Harper, New York.
[43]             Terzaghi K. 1943 Theoretical Soil Mechanics. John Wiley & Sons, New York.
[44]             Poulos H. G. & Davis E. H. 1974 Elastic Solutions for Soil and Rock Mechanics. John Wiley & Sons, New York.
[45]             Fox E. N. 1948 The mean elastic settlement of a uniformly loaded area at a depth below the ground surface. 2nd ICSMFE, 1, 129-132.
[46]             Nishida Y. 1966 Vertical stress and vertical deformation of ground under a deep circular uniform pressure in the semi-infinite. 1st ISRM Congress, Lisbon, Portugal.
Nowachi F., Kiu J. F. E. & Isa O. M. 1996 Use of skirted foundations for offshore structures. Offshore South East Asia Conference, Singapore
Modares Civil Engineering journal
Volume 17, Issue 3
September and October 2017
Pages 104-116