Development and Validation of the Modified Barium Chloride Method for CEC Measurement and Determination of Accurate Exchangeable Calcium Cation Concentration in Carbonated Clayey Soils

Author
Bu-Ali Sina University, Faculty of Eng., Civil Eng. Department, Iran
Abstract
Cation exchange capacity (CEC) is known as the main geo-environmental characteristic of the soil in which in uncontaminated soils it is a direct function of soil swelling, cohesion, and specific surface area. According to the results of the several researches the current method for determination cation exchange capacity and exchangeable cations in carbonated soils has faced to several problems due to the solubility of calcium carbonate. Carbonated soils can be found in many parts of Iran, therefore, in this type of soil, it is essential to study the impact of carbonate calcium concentration of soil upon the measures quantity of soil CEC. In addition, the selection of optimum soil weight for CEC experiment is a common problem in previous researches. The objective of this research is to develop and to validate the modified barium chloride method for CEC measurement and determination of accurate exchangeable calcium cation concentration in carbonated clayey soils. To achieve this objective, the current method of barium chloride is modified by saturation of exchangeable electrolyte with calcium carbonate. In this step, the dried sample of bentonite with the initial weight of 0.3, 0.5, and 0.7 grams were mixed with 30 ml of 0.1 M BaCl2 for two hours period. Then, samples was centrifuged at 2500 rpm for a 5 minutes period. The achieved electrolytes was used for analysis of exchangeable cations and the measurement of barium concentration. Generally, by the use of the current barium chloride method for CEC measurement of carbonated soils, one observes an increase in the measured quantity of CEC of a single soil sample as its carbonate concentration increases. This can be attributed to the solubility of calcium ions and precipitation of barium ions which cause a wrong measured quantity for CEC. Furthermore, for validation of the proposed modified method, a bentonite sample was de-carbonated with acid. The cation exchange capacity of this sample was measured before and after de-carbonation. Moreover, the CEC was measured for laboratory added calcium carbonate to the de-carbonated bentonite. The achieved results show around 60% reduction in the measured quantity of CEC of bentonite in the proposed modified method in comparison to the common barium chloride method. This is attributed to the prevention of the precipitation of barium in the modified method. In addition, according to the achieved results in the validation section of this research, the reduction of the deviation of CEC and summation of exchangeable cations, in some cases was around 80%. For instance, for a sample with initial weight of 0.3 grams, the measured quantity of calcium ion is decrease from 66.45 to 8.09 cmol/kg-soil. The achieved results show that in the modified method the measured quantity of CEC and the summation of exchangeable cations was independent to the weight of carbonate in the soil sample and soil: electrolyte ratio. It should be emphasized that according to the results of this paper, the standard deviation and coefficient of variation of the proposed modified method show 5 to 12 times reduction in comparison to that of for the current barium chloride method.

Keywords


[1] Ouhadi, V.R., Amiri, M.; "Geo-environmental behaviour of nanoclays in interaction with heavy metals contaminant"; Amirkabir J. Civil, 42; 2011, 29-36 (In Persian).
[2] Lamas, F., Irigaray, C. and Chacon, J.; "Geotechnical characterization of carbonate marls for the construction of impermeable dam cores"; Engineering Geology, 66(3-4); 2002, 283-294.
[3] Yong, R.N., Ouhadi, V.R., and Mohamed, A.M.O.; "Physicochemical evaluation of failure of stabilized marl soil"; Proceedings of the 49th Canadian geotechnical conference frontiers in geotechnology, 2; 1996, 769-776.
[4] Yong, R.N.; "Geoenvironmental engineering: contaminated soils, pollutant fate and mitigation";  CRC; New York,  2001.
[5] Ouhadi, V.R., Yong, R.N., Amiri, M., and Ouhadi, M.H.; "Pozzolanic consolidation of stabilized soft clays"; Applied Clay Science, 95; 2014, 111-118.
 [6] Bache, B.W.; "The measurement of cation exchange capacity of soils"; Journal of the Science of Food and Agriculture, 27(3); 1976, 273-280.
[7] Sanqin, W., Zepeng, Z., Yunhua, W., Libing, L., Jiansheng, Z.; "Influence of montmorillonites exchange capacity on the basal spacing of cation–anion organo-montmorillonites"; Materials Research Bulletin, 59; 2014, 59-64.
[8] Dohrmann, R, Genske, D., Karnland, O., Kiviranta, L., Olsson, S., Plotze, M., Sanden, T., Sellin, P., and Svensson, D.; "Inter-laboratory CEC and exchangeable cation study of buffer materials: I. Cu(II)- Triethylenetetramine method"; Clays and Clay Minerals, 60(2); 2012, 162-175.
[9] Wada, K. and Harada, Y.; "Effects of salt concentration and cation species on the measured cation exchange capacity of soils and clays"; Proc. Int. Cay Conf.; Tokyo; 1969, 561-572.
[10] Bascomb, C.L.; "Rapid method for the determination of cation exchange capacity of calcareous and non-calcareous soils"; Journal of the Science of Food and Agriculture, 15(12); 1964, 821- 823.
[11] Gillman, G.P.; "A proposed method for the measurement of exchange properties of highly weathered soils"; Australian Journal of Soil Research, 17(1); 1979, 129-139.
[12] Expert Panel on Soil; "Manual on methods and criteria for harmonized sampling, assessment, monitoring and analysis of the effects of air pollution on forests. Part IIIa. sampling and analysis of soil"; Int. co-operative program on assessment and monitoring of air pollution effects on forests; Institute for Forestry and Game Management; Belgium; 2003.
[13] Holden, A.A., Mayer, K.U. and Ulrich, A.C.; "Evaluating methods for quantifying cation exchange in mildly calcareous sediments in Northern Alberta"; Applied Geochemistry, 27; 2012, 2511-2523.
[14] Komonweeraket, K., Cetin, B., Benson, C., Aydilek, A.H., and Edil, T.B.; "Leaching characteristics of toxic constituents from coal fly ash mixed soils under the influence of pH"; Waste Management, 38; 2015, 174-184.
[15] Hendershot, W.H. and Duquette, M.; "A simple barium chloride method for determining cation exchange capacity and exchangeable cations"; Soil Science Society of America journal (USA), 50; 1986, 605-608.
[16] Schwertfeger, D.M. and Hendershot, W.H.; "Determination of effective cation exchange capacity and exchange acidity by a one-step BaCl2 method"; Soil Science Society of America Journal, 73(3); 2009, 737-743.
[17] Yong, R.N., Ouhadi, V.R.; "Reaction factors impacting on instability of bases on natural and lime-stabilized marls"; Special Lecture, Keynote Paper, International Conference on Special Lecture, Keynote Paper, International Conference on Foundation Failures, Singapore; 1997, 87-97
[18] Amrhein, C. and Suarez, D.L.; "Procedure for determining sodium-calcium selectivity in calcareous and gypsiferous soils"; Soil Science Society of America Journal, 54(4); 1990,  999-1007.
[19] ASTM; "Annual Book of ASTM Standard American Society for Testing and Materials";  Philadelphia; 4, 80, 1994.
[20] Eltantawy, I.N. and Arnold, P.W.; "Reappraisal of ethylene glycol mono-ethyl ether, (EGME) method for surface area estimation of clays"; Soil Science, 24; 1973,  232–238.
[21] Hesse, P.R.; "A textbook of soil chemical analysis"; William Clowes and Sons; London; 1971.
[22] Dohrmann, R.; "Cation exchange capacity methodology III: Correct exchangeable calcium determination of calcareous clays using a new silver-thiourea method"; Applied Clay Science, 34(1-4); 2006c, 47-57.
[23] Dohrmann, R. and Kaufhold, S.; "Three new, quick CEC methods for determining the amounts of exchangeable calcium cations in calcareous clays"; Clays and Clay Minerals, 57(3); 2009, 338-352.
[24] Dohrmann, R.; "Cation exchange capacity methodology I: An efficient model for the detection of incorrect cation exchange capacity and exchangeable cation results"; Applied Clay Sci., 34(1-4); 2006a, 31- 37.
[25] Deiranlou, M.; "Impact of calcium carbonate on the achieved result of cation exchange capacity of clayey soils in three measurement methods"; Master Thesies, Bu-Ali Sina University; 2011, p. 178. (In Persian).
[26] Polemio, M.R. and Rhoades, J.D.; "Determining cation exchange capacity: A new procedure for calcareous and gypsiferous soils"; Soil Science Society of America Journal, 41(3); 1977, 524-528.
[27] Iturri, L.A., and Buschiazzo, D.E.; "Cation exchange capacity and mineralogy of loess soils with different
amounts of volcanic ashes"; CATENA, 121; 2014, 81-87.







[28] Dohrmann, R.; "Cation exchange capacity methodology II: A modified silver-thiourea method"; Applied Clay Science, 34(1-4); 2006b, 38- 46.