Experimental investigation on the influence of hydraulic hysteresis on the California Bearing Ratio of an unsaturated deformable clayey sand

Authors
1 M.Sc. of Highway and Transportation Engineering, Department of Civil Engineering., Isfahan (khorasgan) Branch, Islamic Azad University, Isfahan, Iran
2 Assistant Professor, Department of Civil Engineering, Faculty of Engineering, University of Kashan
Abstract
Many of the past experimental research on the design of road pavement layers was confined to the behavior of saturated pavements materials. Among the experimental studies to determine the road layers properties, California bearing ratio (CBR) has been one of the most common and applicable parameter for determination of the resistance of roads subgrade in both design and practical purposes. An extensive amount of research exist in the literature that explains the behavior of California bearing ratio of saturated soils. However, any change in the degree of saturation of subgrade materials and in particular different hydraulic response in wetting and drying paths can affect the CBR value of a pavement material. In compare to the extensive previous studies on the California bearing ratio of soils, this phenomenon is rarely concerned in the previous studies. The goal of this laboratory research is to examine the influence of the initial compaction void ratio, moisture content, degree of saturation, matrix suction and hydraulic hysteresis on the California bearing ratio of a pavement material. To this end, California bearing ratio of sand-kaolin mixture was measured in a range of initial void ratios and initial water contents along drying and wetting portions of the soil-water characteristic curve. The CBR tests along wetting paths was performed on the soil samples that were dynamically compacted and wetted in a range of initial void ratios and initial water contents. The CBR tests for drying paths was also carried out on the soil samples that were compacted identically to the samples used in wetting tests, but they were air dried for seven days before CBR measurements. The air drying process was achieved from the both ends of soil samples as to maintain a homogenous moisture distribution thorough the soil. This was experimentally verified by measuring the moisture contents of top, middle, and bottom portions of the specimens. The CBR values of soil samples were measured within the loading speed of 1.2 mm/min both for wetting and drying paths. According to the laboratory results, it is observed that the CBR value is increased within the increment of initial soil compaction and matrix suction. Based on the results, it is also observed that the value of California bearing ratio of the understudying soil is decreased within increment of the degree of saturation and initial moisture content of the soil. The experimental data also revealed that the California bearing ratio of the pavement material along the drying and wetting paths are not identical, and for a given suction, the CBR values for drying paths possess lower values than the wetting paths. This hysteretic trend for the change of CBR along drying and wetting paths is explained with regard to the hysteretic behavior of the soil-water characteristic curve.

Keywords


American Society for Testing and Materials (ASTM); "Standard test method for CBR (California Bearing Ratio) of laboratory-compacted soils (D-1883-07)"; ASTM International, Pennsylvania, 2007
[2]American Association of State Highway and Transportation Officials (AASHTO);"Standard Method of Test forthe California Bearing Ratio (T193-99)"; AASHTO StandardSpecifications for Transportation Materials andMethods of Sampling and Testing, Washington. DC, 2003
[3] Davis, E.H. "The California bearing ratio method for the design offlexible roads and runway. Geotechnique"; 1(4),1946, 249-263.
[4] Black, W.P.M. "A method of estimating the California bearing ratio of cohesive soils from plasticity data";Geotechnique, 12(4),1962, 271-282.
[5] Sanchez, FJ."Interpretation of CBR test results under the shear strengthconcept of unsaturated soil mechanics"; In: Proc 3rd IntConf on unsaturatedsoils (USAT 2002), Recife, 2002, 663–668
[6] Talukdar D.K. "A Study of Correlation Between California Bearing Ratio (CBR) Value With Other Properties of Soil"; international Journal of Emerging Technology and Advanced Engineering. Vol. 4, No. 1, 2014, 59-562.
[7] Paraire, J. "Suction tests on CBR-diameter specimens. The bearing capacitysuctionrelation"; Transport and Road Research Lab. (TRRL), 1987.
[8] Sivakumar V, Tan W.C. "CBR, undrained strength and yielding characteristics of compacted tills"; In: d.C.Juca, Marinho (Editor),Unsaturated Soils, proceedings of the Third International Conference on Unsaturated Soils, UNSAT 2002, Recife, Brazil, 2002, 657-661.
[9]Vogrig, M. MacDonald, A. Vanapalli, S.K.., Siekmeier, J., Roberson, R., and Garven, E. "A laboratory technique for estimating the resilient modulus of unsaturated soil specimens from CBR and  unconfined compression tests"; Proceedings of the 56th Canadian Geotechnical Conference, Winnipeg, 2003, 99-106.
[10] Ampadu S. "A laboratory investigation into the effect of water content on the CBR of a subgrade soil"; In: T. Schanz (Editor), Experimental Unsaturated Soil Mechanics, Springer Berlin Heidelberg,2007, 137-144
[11] Purwana Y.M., Nikraz H., Jitsangiam P. "Experimantal Study of Suction-Monitored CBR Test on Sand-Kaolin Clay Mixture"; International Journal of Geomate; Vol. 3, No. 2,2012, 419-422.
[12] Mirzaii A., Yasrobi S. "Influence of Initial Dry Density on Soil-Water Characteristics of two Compacted Soils";Geotechnique Letters 2,2012, 193-198
[13]American Society for Testing and Materials (ASTM);"Standard test method for laboratory compaction characteristic of soil using standard effort (12,400 fr-lbf/ft3 (600 kN-m/m3)) (D-698-07)"; ASTM International, Pennsylvania, 2007
[14] Xirong W., Junming S. "Research on the Impact of Moisture Content on the CBR Value of Shanxiloess";Advanced Materials Research Vols. Vol. 838-841, 2014, 80-83