مقایسه عملکرد فروریزش دیوارهای برشی فولادی مرکزگرا و متداول تحت چارچوب ارزیابی احتمالاتی FEMA P-695

نوع مقاله : مقاله پژوهشی

نویسنده
دکتری عمران-سازه، گروه مهندسی عمران، واحد تهران جنوب، دانشگاه آزاد اسلامی، تهران، ایران
10.48311/mcej.2026.117841.82877
چکیده
دیوارهای برشی فولادی (SPSW) سیستم‌های باربر لرزه‌ای کارآمدی هستند، اما تغییرشکل‌های پسماند قابل توجه پس از زلزله‌های شدید، چالش اصلی آن‌هاست. این پژوهش با هدف رفع این نقیصه، عملکرد لرزه‌ای سیستم دیوار برشی فولادی مرکزگرا (SC-SPSW) را به صورت عددی ارزیابی و با سیستم متداول مقایسه می‌کند. بدین منظور، مدل‌های دوبعدی برای سازه‌های ۳ و ۹ طبقه با هر دو سیستم در نرم‌افزار OpenSees توسعه داده شد. عملکرد لرزه‌ای با استفاده از تحلیل‌های استاتیکی و دینامیکی غیرخطی و در نهایت چارچوب FEMA P-695 ارزیابی گردید. اهمیت این پژوهش در تولید داده‌های کمّی مقایسه‌ای جهت ارزیابی عملکرد فروریزش این دو سیستم و شناسایی وابستگی شدید قابلیت اطمینان SC-SPSW به ارتفاع سازه است. نتایج نشان داد که سیستم SC-SPSW در هر دو ارتفاع، با کاهش بیش از ۸۰٪ در تغییرشکل‌های پسماند، قابلیت مرکزگرایی فوق‌العاده‌ای دارد. با این حال، در ارزیابی فروریزش، یک رفتار دوگانه مشاهده شد: در حالی که مدل ۹ طبقه SC-SPSW برتری قاطعی در ظرفیت فروریزش داشت، مدل ۳ طبقه آن با احتمال فروریزش ۴۲٪ در سطح MCE، آسیب‌پذیری غیرقابل قبولی از خود نشان داد. این یافته‌ها کارایی سیستم مرکزگرا را به عنوان جایگزینی مناسب برای سازه‌های میان‌مرتبه تأیید می‌کند، اما بر عدم قطعیت و ریسک بالای استفاده از آن در سازه‌های کوتاه‌مرتبه تأکید دارد.
کلیدواژه‌ها
موضوعات

عنوان مقاله English

Comparative Collapse Performance of Self-Centering and Conventional Steel Plate Shear Walls Using the FEMA P-695 Methodology

نویسنده English

Pooya Arezoomand Langarudi
Department of Civil Engineering, ST.C., Islamic Azad University, Tehran, Iran
چکیده English

Conventional Steel Plate Shear Walls (SPSWs) are highly effective seismic force-resisting systems, recognized for their substantial initial stiffness and robust energy dissipation capacities. However, their primary drawback is a pronounced susceptibility to large permanent residual drifts following severe earthquakes, rendering structures unusable and complicating post-earthquake recovery. The Self-Centering Steel Plate Shear Wall (SC-SPSW) was developed to overcome this limitation. By utilizing post-tensioned cables, a rocking connection mechanism, and a yielding steel web plate acting as a replaceable structural fuse, the system offers robust re-centering capabilities to minimize deformations. To generate systematic comparative data and address existing computational gaps, this study rigorously evaluates the seismic collapse performance of independently designed SC-SPSW and conventional SPSW systems utilizing the FEMA P-695 probabilistic framework.

Nonlinear single-span two-dimensional models of 3-story and 9-story archetype buildings were developed and validated in OpenSees. These archetypes were categorized by specific aspect ratios to represent low-rise and mid-rise structures. The computational models incorporated advanced fiber-based cross-sections and precise material constitutive laws to accurately simulate the complex yielding mechanics of the infill plates and rocking connections. The evaluation systematically employed the FEMA P-695 probabilistic framework. Nonlinear static pushover analyses first established key seismic parameters, including overstrength (Ω0) and period-based ductility (μT). Subsequently, comprehensive Incremental Dynamic Analyses (IDA) using a suite of 44 far-field ground motion records traced the structural response to global collapse, specifically quantifying the Adjusted Collapse Margin Ratio (ACMR) and the probability of collapse at the Maximum Considered Earthquake (MCE) intensity level.

The analytical findings revealed a highly height-dependent dual behavior. From an economic standpoint, the SC-SPSW configuration demanded a 22.5% and 26.6% increase in total structural weight for the 3-story and 9-story models, respectively. This increase is necessary because boundary frames must be heavily reinforced to resist high post-tensioning forces. Nevertheless, the system demonstrated exceptional self-centering, successfully reducing median residual inter-story drifts by over 80% in the 9-story model compared to the conventional baseline. Furthermore, pushover results indicated that while conventional SPSWs suffer a reduction in ductility and overstrength as building height increases, the SC-SPSW actually improves. The mid-rise SC-SPSW achieved a ductility capacity of 11.1, which is 66.3% higher than its conventional counterpart.

Consequently, the 9-story SC-SPSW model exhibited superior collapse capacity. Its median collapse capacity SCT reached 3.98g (a 42% enhancement over the conventional SPSW), and it achieved an ACMR of 3.32, safely exceeding the required 1.66 limit and yielding an MCE collapse probability of merely 4%. In stark contrast, the 3-story SC-SPSW displayed unacceptable vulnerability. Its median collapse capacity plummeted to 2.02g (56% lower than the conventional system), resulting in a critically high MCE collapse probability of 42% and failing the FEMA P-695 safety criteria.

Rather than universally classifying the SC-SPSW as resilient, this research confirms it acts as a highly resilient alternative specifically for mid-rise buildings. Conversely, it highlights the severe risks of applying current design assumptions to rigid, low-rise structures, where the system provides self-centering but lacks sufficient life-safety margins. The study strongly advocates for developing height-dependent design procedures and revising constant response modification factors to ensure uniform safety across varying aspect ratios.

کلیدواژه‌ها English

Steel Plate Shear Wall (SPSW)
Self-Centering
Post-Tensioned Cables
Incremental Dynamic Analysis (IDA)
Performance-Based Assessment
FEMA P-695

مقالات آماده انتشار، پذیرفته شده
انتشار آنلاین از 27 آبان 1405